Here are the results! Idea source links will follow.
|Favor bag table|
|Blowing out the candles|
|Cake ready for cutting, and ice cream cups|
|Closeup of cake|
|Closeup of tissue paper pompoms and favor bags|
Funfetti vanilla cake with colored vanilla icing
Chocolate chip ice cream
Goldfish (Elmo loves his goldfish!)
Soda for grown-ups
Ice cream idea
Elmo printables - used for cup stickers, banner clouds, lettering, and decorations
Original inspiration behind the cake. I improvised.
Cookies - The sticks kept making the Oreos come apart so I improvised again.
Favor bags and tablewear from Party City